There are two possibilities here:

1) Make you are not clicking on the link that says "Login: If your membership is paid up and you need to login for the first time" text, that is meant to be news.  Instead click on login button found in the "Member Login" section in the upper left hand corner.

2) You missed.  Try a little higher next time.  But don't feel bad, this seems to happen a lot*.

Don't believe me?  Right before you click on the 'Login' button look at lower left hand corner of Internet Explorer or Firefox.  If your mouse is over the 'Login' button nothing will appear there, but if you see http://www.airheads.org/component/option,com_registration/task,lostPassword/ that means your mouse is hovering over the Need a New or Forgotten password? link [not the 'Login' link].

* On a related note, not everyone in this club has 20/20 vision, in fact the median is far from.  But fear not, the webmaster is working on a way to increase the font size.